Ukraine's general staff reported this morning that Russia has lost 40,000 troops in only six months of war. (The Kyiv Independent.) British intelligence estimates nearer to 25,000 Russian deaths, and the U.S. defense department has put the figure at 15,000. Any of the three estimates, however, is a shocking and possibly unsustainable loss of personnel in such a short time.
Ukraine also claims to have destroyed almost 2,000 Russian tanks, nearly 4,000 armored combat vehicles, 883 artillery systems, 256 multiple rocket launchers, 117 air defense systems, 222 warplanes, 190 helicopters and scores of other weapons and facilitators of war.
Asks The NY Times: "Could Russia be approaching a point of exhaustion?" Ben Barry, a senior fellow at Britain's International Institute for Strategic Studies, says "Russia has assembled what I call a steamroller. We don’t know at what point Russia will run out of steam." Barry adds that the Kremlin may reach a "culminating point," a situation in which its "offensive runs out of supplies or sustains so many casualties that it can’t be sustained." There are signs that Russia is rapidly approaching just that.
In the Donbas, Putin's forces captured the last major city, Lysychansk, earlier this month. Yet Russia's offensive in eastern Ukraine has stalled, leaving large areas of the Donetsk province unoccupied. The Russian dictator has a much bigger problem along Ukraine's southern axis. In recent days, Ukrainian forces have freed 44 towns and villages along the front, says the region's military governor.
Analysts have offered three explanations for Russia's seeming slowdown. It may be the Kremlin simply desires a breather for its troops, especially in eastern Ukraine. But strategic studies Professor Phillips O’Brien, at Scotland's University of St. Andrews, argues that data from NASA satellites "show Russian
ranged fire declining enormously" in the Donetsk province — i.e., artillery fire unreliant on troop advancements.
A third explanation is Ukraine's enormous firepower provided by newly arrived, U.S. HIMARS. Ukrainian forces claim to have struck 50 Russian ammunition depots with these long-range, multiple rocket systems. Today, for the third time, Ukraine also hit a vital logistics route for Russian forces in Kherson, the Antonivskyi bridge. Reuters reports that Russia has closed the bridge — which was its supply lifeline from Crimea — because of heavy damage.
London's Royal United Services Institute contends quite reasonably that daily battleline developments are less important than the long-term strengths of both armies in training, logistics and supplies. At least along the southern axis, Ukraine is crippling Russia's supply lines.
London's strategic institute critically adds that Ukraine’s counteroffensive in the south must be sustained. Otherwise, President Zelensky's government risks "a symmetrical stalemate that can only bring about an attritional conflict, risking Ukraine’s exhaustion."
In a separate article, The NY Times relates that "Ukrainian forces are under pressure to demonstrate to their Western allies that they cannot only mount a muscular defense but are capable of reclaiming lost land." That pressure currently centers on Ukraine's push in the Kherson region. That's where Western allies must intensify and sustain their military support of Ukraine. A massive offensive is emphatically essential — now — before the Russian autocrat annexes the Kherson province.
This official act would most likely engulf the region within Russia's nuclear doctrine of defense. And that, in turn, would likely spell the end of the West's military supplies to Ukraine's offensive forces.