top of page

Heinrich Hegseth or Bumbling Mustache Pete?

  • pmcarp4
  • Jun 21
  • 2 min read

Or, a futile thought experiment.


The challenge lies in discerning whether the last word of the second aphorism is, or shall be shown to be, the final word: playwright Eugene O'Neill, "There is no present or future - only the past, happening over and over again - now"; political theorist-sociologist Karl Marx, "History repeats itself, first as a tragedy, second as a farce."

Present testimony, followed by the past's.


The leader had been in office "for six months ... but he did not yet possess absolute power." A higher authority still commanded "the regular army."


Despite "newspaper stories about [the foreign leader's] erratic behavior and his government's brutality..., throughout America there was a widely held belief that ... surely no modern state could behave in such a manner. At the State Department, however, [the U.S. ambassador] read dispatch after dispatch in which [were described the nation's] rapid descent from democratic republic to brutal dictatorship."


Arrests were being made of priests and politicians. The U.S. embassy's general consul "sensed a rising 'hysteria' among" the leader's immediate subordinates, "expressed as a belief 'that the only safety lies in getting everybody in jail.'" In the Garden of Beasts: Love, Terror, and an American Family in Hitler's Berlin, Erik Larson, 2011.


There should be no self-reproach when stumped by discernment's challenge: In the end, which is to be? — America's tragedy of historical magnitude, or its darkest comedy of all farce.


The inescapable-thus-self-pardoning kicker, of course, the unknowable future. And that itself is buried in the absolute unknown degree of magnitude wrapped in philosopher George Santayana's, third, challenge-related aphorism about the condemning of mass forgottenness to the past's repetition.

 
 
 

Comments


This site relies on your support. Please help put it on firmer financial ground.
You'll feel good and I'll be most grateful. With thanks, —PM

Donate Now

$
bottom of page